New A.I. Test: Can Machines Make Art?
At what point does artificial intelligence meet or surpass the level of human intelligence?
That’s a question that’s been bouncing around the halls of computer science (and science fiction) for decades. The existing go-to system — called the Turing Test, after pioneering computer scientist Alan Turing — requires that a machine be able to essentially fool a human in one-on-one conversation.
Dream This Up: Structures Meld Art And Design
Mark O. Riedl, computer researcher at the Georgia Institute of Technology, has proposed a new kind of test focused on the idea of artistic creativity. The Lovelace 2.0 test would require an aspiring A.I. machine to create a range of creative works — paintings, stories, poems, architectural designs — that expert and unbiased observers would conclude were designed by a human.
It’s not a precisely new idea, as that 2.0 designation suggests. The concept is a variation on a 2001 proposal that also focuses on the idea of creativity in human intelligence. The original Lovelace test requires an A.I. machine to produce a work of art in such a way that the machine’s designers can’t explain how it happened.
Digital ‘Head Dome’ Immerses You In Art
Riedl, associate professor and director of Georgia Tech’s Entertainment Intelligence Lab, contends that the 1.0 test is flawed — in that the designers would always be able to deduce how the art was created. Instead, he suggests a more complex methodology which hews closer to the Turing Test. If a robot can make art indistinguishable from that of a human — to an expert outside evaluator under specified conditions — then the machine has achieved human-level intelligence.
“Many forms of creativity necessitate intelligence,” Riedl writes in his proposal. “In the spirit of [the Turning Test] the Lovelace 2.0 Test asks that artificial agents comprehend instruction and create at the amateur level.”
On a lark, we ran the Lovelace Test on our central supercomputer here at Discovery News HQ, SAL 9000, to see if he could create a poem. As usual, SAL took the opportunity to crack wise. An uncommonly sarcastic supercomputer, our SAL.
Write a poem and I’ll be a hero?
An artist like Robert DeNiro?
Well, give me some time
To think up a rhyme